Curator Watchlist

https://www.curatorwatchlist.com › wednesday

Wednesday

A glossy, crowd-pleasing mystery-comedy with a strong lead performance and enough gothic personality to stand out. It’s at its best when it leans into Wednesday’s deadpan voice, schoolyard intrigue, and monster-of-the-week plotting; the larger mythology is more uneven, but the show remains easy to binge.

53% (504,140)

Wednesday

Where to watch: Netflix

TV Show · Sci-Fi & Fantasy · Mystery

2022 · ★ 53% (504K)

The wait has been torture.

Starring: Jenna Ortega, Steve Buscemi, Emma Myers

Overview

Smart, sarcastic and a little dead inside, Wednesday Addams investigates twisted mysteries while making new friends — and foes — at Nevermore Academy.

Production

MGM Television, Millar Gough Ink, Toluca Pictures, Tim Burton Productions

Cast

Jenna Ortega, Steve Buscemi, Emma Myers, Hunter Doohan, Joy Sunday, Moosa Mostafa, Georgie Farmer, Isaac Ordonez, Owen Painter, Billie Piper, Luyanda Unati Lewis-Nyawo, Victor Dorobantu, Noah B. Taylor, Evie Templeton, Luis Guzmán, Catherine Zeta-Jones

Where to watch

Netflix

Curator Review

Verdict

A glossy, crowd-pleasing mystery-comedy with a strong lead performance and enough gothic personality to stand out. It’s at its best when it leans into Wednesday’s deadpan voice, schoolyard intrigue, and monster-of-the-week plotting; the larger mythology is more uneven, but the show remains easy to binge.

Best for

  • fans of dark teen mysteries with a comedic edge
  • viewers who like gothic school settings and supernatural casework
  • people who want a stylish, mainstream Netflix binge
  • audiences drawn to sharp, sarcastic lead characters

Skip if

  • you want tightly plotted mysteries with no teen-drama detours
  • you dislike YA romance and love-triangle energy
  • you prefer horror that is genuinely scary rather than playful
  • you want a complete story with no ongoing franchise setup

Overview

Wednesday turns a familiar franchise into a slick, highly watchable teen mystery with a strong sense of style. Jenna Ortega’s deadpan performance is the engine: she makes the character feel both iconic and freshly sharpened, and the show knows how to build around that attitude with gothic production design, brisk episode hooks, and a steady stream of oddball supporting players.

Worth noting

The first season is the essential run, balancing whodunit plotting, monster lore, and school politics with the best rhythm the series has found so far. Later seasons continue to lean on the same strengths, though the show can get a little busier and more franchise-minded as it expands its mythology. Even so, it remains an easy recommendation if you want something polished, accessible, and slightly macabre.

Bottom line

It is not the darkest or smartest mystery series on television, but it is one of the most efficient at delivering a bingeable mood. The humor is broad but controlled, the visuals are memorable, and the show’s confidence in its own tone goes a long way.

Recommended similar titles

Buffy the Vampire Slayer

1997 · Where to watch: Hulu

A foundational mix of supernatural casework, sharp character banter, and school-age outsider energy that pairs well with Wednesday’s tone.

Veronica Mars

2004 · Where to watch: Netflix, Hulu, Plex

If you like the mystery engine more than the fantasy, this is the gold-standard teen sleuth series with a similarly quick, sardonic lead.

Chilling Adventures of Sabrina

2018 · Where to watch: Netflix

Comparable gothic YA atmosphere, occult mythology, and glossy Netflix-era melodrama, with a darker, more overtly supernatural edge.

Locke & Key

2020 · Where to watch: Netflix

Another Netflix-friendly blend of family secrets, supernatural puzzles, and serialized mystery with strong genre-forward production design.

A Series of Unfortunate Events

2017 · Where to watch: Netflix

For the dry wit, stylized world-building, and playful gothic sensibility, this is a great tonal companion.

The Umbrella Academy

2019 · Where to watch: Netflix

Stylized, eccentric, and built around damaged misfits navigating supernatural chaos with a strong binge factor.

Twin Peaks

1990 · Where to watch: Paramount Plus Premium, Paramount Plus Essential, MUBI

A classic for small-town mystery, eerie atmosphere, and off-kilter humor, especially if you like the show’s strange-people-in-a-strange-place vibe.

Pretty Little Liars

2010 · Where to watch: Hulu, Max

If the appeal is the serialized secrets, school intrigue, and constant cliffhangers, this is a prime bingeable match.

The OA

2016 · Where to watch: Netflix

For viewers who want a more mysterious, emotionally strange, and genre-bending take on young-adult supernatural storytelling.

Pushing Daisies

2007

A whimsical, visually distinctive mystery series with a macabre-romantic sensibility and a highly crafted tone.

Themes

gothic coming-of-age, teen mystery, supernatural investigation, outsider identity, dark comedy, boarding school politics, monster mythology, friendship and rivalry

Topics

gothic, YA mystery, supernatural, dark comedy, boarding school, teen drama, whodunit, macabre, bingeable, stylized

Open Wednesday (2022) on Curator TV