Curator Watchlist
A sharp, messy college-coming-of-age comedy with real bite, especially if you like horny, anxious, identity-driven humor and a fast, joke-dense pace. It’s strongest as a portrait of self-invention and social panic, though the tone can feel broad and uneven at times.
Where to watch: Buy
Thu
Created by: Benito Skinner
Starring: Benito Skinner, Wally Baram, Mary Beth Barone
Closeted former football player and homecoming king Benny becomes fast friends with Carmen, a high school outsider on a mission to fit in at all costs. With guidance from Benny's older sister and her campus-legend boyfriend, Benny and Carmen juggle horrible hookups, flavored vodka, and fake IDs.
Benito Skinner
Benito Skinner, Wally Baram, Mary Beth Barone, Adam DiMarco, Rish Shah
A sharp, messy college-coming-of-age comedy with real bite, especially if you like horny, anxious, identity-driven humor and a fast, joke-dense pace. It’s strongest as a portrait of self-invention and social panic, though the tone can feel broad and uneven at times.
Overcompensating is built around a very specific kind of social panic: the terror of being seen, and the equally exhausting effort of becoming someone else to survive. Benito Skinner turns that anxiety into a brisk, often very funny campus comedy that mixes sexual confusion, status games, and desperate self-mythology. The result is less a glossy teen show than a loud, bruised, and self-aware one.
The series works best when it leans into awkward intimacy and the absurdity of trying to perform the “right” version of yourself. Its humor can be broad, but the emotional core is clear enough to keep it grounded. The supporting characters help give the show shape, especially in the friendship dynamics and the constant collision between image and reality.
As a first-season comedy, it already has a distinct voice, though it can feel uneven as it balances raunch, sincerity, and social satire. If the show continues, the biggest upside is that it has room to sharpen its character work and deepen the emotional stakes without losing the manic energy that makes it easy to binge.
A similarly frank, funny, and emotionally open coming-of-age series about sex, identity, and social awkwardness, with strong ensemble chemistry and binge appeal.
College-set, fast-moving, and built around messy friendships, hookups, and identity exploration with a bright comic rhythm.
A smart, intimate queer dramedy that balances embarrassment, self-discovery, and tenderness with a very human tone.
If the appeal is sexual panic, identity chaos, and unfiltered jokes, this animated comedy pushes those themes even further.
A gentler queer coming-of-age alternative that still centers self-acceptance, friendship, and first love.
For viewers drawn to sharp, confessional humor and a protagonist using wit and chaos to mask vulnerability.
Not college-set, but it shares the same mix of abrasive comedy, emotional insecurity, and a strong central voice.
A high-school-to-college-adjacent coming-of-age comedy about status anxiety, desire, and trying to reinvent yourself.
For the glossy teen ensemble energy and social hierarchy dynamics, though with a mystery framework instead of pure comedy.
A biting, very funny show about ambition, embarrassment, and the absurdity of chasing relevance.
If you like characters spiraling through self-delusion and social performance, this is a darker, sharper option.
A painfully funny look at adolescent humiliation and identity formation, with a strong cringe-comedy sensibility.
closeted identity, self-invention, friendship, college life, social anxiety, status and popularity, sexual awakening, coming-of-age
queer comedy, coming-of-age, college setting, raunchy, cringe humor, bingeable, identity crisis, friendship dynamics, millennial/gen-z, campus satire