An ambitious Middle-earth side story with strong visual ideas and a few rousing battle beats, but it’s held back by thin characterization, uneven pacing, and the sense that it’s stretching a slim legend into feature length. Fans of Tolkien lore and adult fantasy animation may find enough to enjoy; others may feel… Read more
The Lord of the Rings: The War of the Rohirrim
Where to watch: Buy
Movie · Animation · Fantasy
Thu · 2h 14m
Director: Kenji Kamiyama
Starring: Brian Cox, Gaia Wise, Luke Pasqualino
Overview
A sudden attack by Wulf, a clever and traitorous lord of Rohan seeking vengeance for the death of his father, forces Helm Hammerhand, the King of Rohan, and his people to make a daring last stand in the ancient stronghold of the Hornburg.
Director
Kenji Kamiyama
Cast
Brian Cox, Gaia Wise, Luke Pasqualino
Curator Review
Verdict
An ambitious Middle-earth side story with strong visual ideas and a few rousing battle beats, but it’s held back by thin characterization, uneven pacing, and the sense that it’s stretching a slim legend into feature length. Fans of Tolkien lore and adult fantasy animation may find enough to enjoy; others may feel the emotional weight never fully lands.
Best for
Tolkien completists
viewers curious about anime-style fantasy
fans of siege warfare and tragic medieval epics
audiences who enjoy lore expansions over standalone storytelling
Skip if
you want the emotional sweep of the original trilogy
you dislike prequels built from sparse source material
you’re sensitive to uneven animation or hybrid 2D/3D presentation
you prefer character-driven fantasy over battle-first plotting
Overview
The War of the Rohirrim is an interesting idea before it is a fully satisfying movie: a Middle-earth legend retold through anime, with a grim, old-world sense of honor, vengeance, and doomed kingship. The setting and premise have real appeal, and the film occasionally finds the scale and melancholy that Tolkien’s world calls for.
Worth noting
But the story is stretched thin. Characters are sketched rather than deeply developed, and the emotional arcs often feel rushed or undercooked. The result is a film that moves with the momentum of a siege but not always with the depth of a great saga.
Bottom line
Still, there’s enough craft here to make it worth a look for the right audience, especially if you’re interested in seeing Middle-earth interpreted in a different visual language. It’s more of a respectable lore appendix than an essential chapter, but it has its moments.
Top Letterboxd reviews
linhares_ (5★) · 4329 likes
they really teased Gandalf like he's the next guy to join the avengers
Jamie Gilmore (4★) · 3674 likes
🚨 Sound the alarm 🚨 we have a third and fourth named woman in Lord of the Rings
Sethsreviews (2★) · 1848 likes
As someone who has been a lifelong LOTR obsessor (both books and the trilogy - books more so in my early years), I got very little out of this. It feels like a very shielded attempt at grasping at whatever straws left by Tolkien, in this case literally a few pages worth of material stretched into a 2 hour+ film (and one that felt more like 4 hours, to be honest). Spending time with characters that present absolutely zero to
PT99 (3★) · 1772 likes
Ladies, don't you hate it when you try to keep things platonic with your childhood best friend and he immediately pivots to genocide? 6/10 2024 Ranked2020s Ranked
davidehrlich (1.5★) · 1104 likes
In this dark age of assembly line sequels, remakes, and spin-offs, a feature-length anime film set within Middle-earth — specifically in the version of it that Peter Jackson immortalized with his “Lord of the Rings” trilogy — qualifies as an appreciably novel method for Warner Bros. to milk a few more dollars from J.R.R. Tolkien’s fantasy universe. Regrettable as it is that “The Lord of the Rings: The War of the Rohirrim” is a paper-thin prequel that stretches a single
Themes
vengeance, siege warfare, honor and duty, dynastic conflict, tragic fantasy, kingdom under threat, loyalty and betrayal, mythic history