Curator Watchlist

https://www.curatorwatchlist.com › immaculate

Immaculate

A glossy, pulpy religious-horror thriller with strong atmosphere and a committed lead performance, but it leans heavily on familiar genre beats and shock value. The setting, production design, and body-horror imagery do a lot of the heavy lifting, while the script is more effective as a provocative premise than as… Read more

Immaculate

Where to watch: Buy

Movie · Horror · Mystery

Wed · 1h 29m

Director: Michael Mohan

Starring: Sydney Sweeney, Álvaro Morte, Simona Tabasco

Overview

An American nun embarks on a new journey when she joins a remote convent in the Italian countryside. However, her warm welcome quickly turns into a living nightmare when she discovers her new home harbours a sinister secret and unspeakable horrors.

Director

Michael Mohan

Cast

Sydney Sweeney, Álvaro Morte, Simona Tabasco

Curator Review

Verdict

A glossy, pulpy religious-horror thriller with strong atmosphere and a committed lead performance, but it leans heavily on familiar genre beats and shock value. The setting, production design, and body-horror imagery do a lot of the heavy lifting, while the script is more effective as a provocative premise than as a fully satisfying mystery.

Best for

  • Viewers who like convent, cult, or Catholic-horror settings
  • Fans of body horror and pregnancy-related dread
  • People in the mood for a stylish, camp-adjacent thriller
  • Audiences who enjoy a strong central performance carrying a flawed script

Skip if

  • You want subtle, slow-burn horror over jump scares
  • You’re tired of religious-horror tropes and possession-adjacent plotting
  • You dislike body horror or pregnancy anxiety as a central device
  • You need a tightly plotted mystery with strong payoff

Overview

Immaculate is the kind of horror movie that knows exactly what image it wants to burn into your brain. The Italian convent setting gives it instant gothic texture, and the film makes good use of corridors, candlelight, ritual, and bodily unease to create a sticky, anxious mood. Sydney Sweeney is fully committed, especially once the movie shifts from uneasy mystery into outright nightmare mode.

Worth noting

What holds it back is familiarity. The movie often feels like it is remixing better-known religious-horror ideas rather than discovering a new one, and the script can be thin where the visuals are rich. It’s strongest when it leans into dread, grotesque escalation, and the absurdity of its premise; weaker when it tries to sound deeper than it is.

Bottom line

Still, as a slick, crowd-pleasing horror ride, it works more often than it doesn’t. If you want a polished genre piece with a nasty streak, strong atmosphere, and a lead performance that never phones it in, it’s worth a look. If you want something genuinely fresh or psychologically layered, it may leave you wanting more.

Top Letterboxd reviews

haley (3.5★) · 21326 likes

nothing scarier than being pregnant

Ben Clay (3.5★) · 19065 likes

I would like to see the baby

Kylo (3.5★) · 16408 likes

Sydney Sweeney’s character went through blood, sweat and tears in this movie but she had no intention of learning any Italian.

cob (4.5★) · 8927 likes

sydney screamy

cerys (2.5★) · 7430 likes

what i go through every time my period is late

Recommended similar titles

Rosemary's Baby

1968 · Drama, Horror, Thriller · 2h 18m · R · Where to watch: fuboTV, Paramount Plus Premium, Paramount Plus Essential

The definitive pregnancy-paranoia horror film, with a slow tightening of dread and a sinister institutional backdrop.

The First Omen

2024

Shares the same blend of Catholic dread, conspiracy, and escalating bodily horror, but with a more elaborate mythic framework.

The Omen

1976 · Horror, Thriller · 1h 51m · R

A classic of religious unease and apocalyptic menace, balancing polished suspense with occult dread.

The Exorcist

1973 · Horror, Drama · 2h 2m · R

The benchmark for Catholic horror, combining faith, bodily violation, and escalating terror with real dramatic weight.

Black Narcissus

1947 · Drama · 1h 40m · NR · Where to watch: fuboTV, Max, Artiflix

A key influence for convent-set psychological tension, repression, and the oppressive power of a remote religious setting.

The Devils

1971 · Drama, History, Horror · 1h 52m · R

For viewers drawn to blasphemous historical horror, institutional corruption, and feverish religious imagery.

Saint Maud

2020

A more intimate, psychologically intense take on faith, isolation, and bodily obsession.

Carrie

1976 · Horror, Thriller · 1h 38m · R · Where to watch: fuboTV, Philo, MGM Plus

A landmark of female bodily horror and social punishment, with a similar mix of empathy, rage, and spectacle.

Suspiria

1977 · Horror · 1h 39m · R · Where to watch: Philo

For its stylized nightmare logic, occult atmosphere, and vivid use of color, architecture, and dread.

The Innocents

1961 · Horror, Mystery, Drama · 1h 40m · NR

A refined gothic horror about repression, ambiguity, and the terror of a sealed environment.

Midsommar

2019 · Horror, Drama, Mystery · 2h 27m · R · Where to watch: Max

For cult ritual, bodily unease, and the way bright, beautiful settings can become deeply threatening.

The Lodge

2020

A cold, isolated horror story built on psychological pressure, grief, and a claustrophobic setting.

Themes

religious horror, body horror, pregnancy anxiety, convent isolation, female survival, gothic atmosphere, cult secrecy, mystery thriller

Topics

religious horror, body horror, pregnancy, gothic, convent, cult, female-led, thriller, nightmare, campy

Open Immaculate (Wed ) on Curator TV