Curator Watchlist

https://www.curatorwatchlist.com › chances-are

Chances Are

A breezy, oddball fantasy-romance with an appealing early Robert Downey Jr. performance, but its premise is so awkward that the movie never fully escapes the discomfort it creates.… Read more

Chances Are

Where to watch: Buy

Movie · Fantasy · Comedy

Fri · 1h 48m

Director: Emile Ardolino

Starring: Cybill Shepherd, Robert Downey Jr., Ryan O'Neal

Overview

Louie Jeffries is happily married to Corinne. On their first anniversary, Louie is killed crossing the road. Louie is reincarnated as Alex Finch, and twenty years later, fate brings Alex and Louie's daughter, Miranda, together. It's not until Alex is invited to Louie's home that he begins to remember his former life, wife and best friend. Of course, there's also the problem that he's attracted to Louie's/his own daughter.

Director

Emile Ardolino

Cast

Cybill Shepherd, Robert Downey Jr., Ryan O'Neal

Curator Review

Verdict

A breezy, oddball fantasy-romance with an appealing early Robert Downey Jr. performance, but its premise is so awkward that the movie never fully escapes the discomfort it creates. If you can accept a high-concept soap opera with a soft-focus 80s charm, it has enough sweetness and comic invention to be interesting.

Best for

  • fans of offbeat 1980s romantic comedies
  • viewers curious about early Robert Downey Jr.
  • people who like reincarnation or afterlife premises
  • audiences open to sentimental, lightly surreal studio comedies

Skip if

  • you are sensitive to incest-adjacent plotlines
  • you want a clean, modern romcom
  • you dislike dated 80s tonal gloss
  • you need the premise to stay emotionally believable

Overview

Chances Are is the kind of late-80s studio fantasy that feels both polished and wildly misguided. Emile Ardolino stages it with a light touch, and the movie keeps trying to be charming, wistful, and whimsical even as the premise pushes into deeply uncomfortable territory. The result is a film that is easier to admire as an artifact than to embrace without reservations.

Worth noting

Robert Downey Jr. gives the movie its spark, bringing wit and restlessness to a role that could have been purely schematic. Cybill Shepherd and Ryan O'Neal help sell the romantic-comedy machinery, and the film’s best stretches lean into its reincarnation premise with genuine curiosity rather than shock value. There is a real sweetness in the way it imagines fate, memory, and second chances.

Bottom line

But the central relationship logic is hard to ignore, and the ending asks for a level of acceptance that many viewers simply will not grant. For some, that tension will make it memorable; for others, it will make it unwatchable. It is a curious, sometimes charming misfire with a strong cult-movie aftertaste.

Top Letterboxd reviews

Kat (1.5★) · 227 likes

Shooter McGavin dies in a car accident and gets reincarnated as RDJ, but the angels in heaven forget to give him an amnesia shot. So when he meets his former wife and friend his memories come back. He convinces his former wife of who he is and they almost boink, but then he helps his friend boink his wife instead. The angels come down to earth and give him his amnesia shot so he forgets who his true soul is.… more

Satchel (2.5★) · 157 likes

who thought the right ending to this movie would be to erase the dads memories so that he ends up getting together with his own daughter?

eely (2.5★) · 127 likes

imagine getting two lives and getting to make out with cybill shepherd in both of them

irene 🎞 (3★) · 123 likes

young rdj im free on thursday night

carina ☆ (2.5★) · 88 likes

You know what’s fun when you go through an actor’s filmography? You stumble across the most unhinged story ideas for romcoms (spoiler ahead, but I assume nobody wants to watch this anyway). Like, what do you mean? A husband and soon-to-be father gets hit by a truck and dies. He is then reincarnated as Alex Finch (RDJ), falls in love with his daughter from his past life, regains his memories, and hooks up with his former wife — until some… more

Recommended similar titles

Peggy Sue Got Married

1986 · Comedy, Drama, Fantasy · 1h 43m · PG-13

A similarly playful time-bending fantasy about memory, regret, and rethinking a life through an impossible premise.

Somewhere in Time

1980 · Drama, Fantasy, Romance · 1h 43m · PG · Where to watch: Amazon Prime Video, Amazon Prime Video with Ads

A romantic fantasy built on longing, destiny, and the emotional pull of crossing time to reach someone again.

Defending Your Life

1991

A warm, witty afterlife comedy that uses the supernatural to explore love, fear, and self-knowledge.

Big

1988 · Fantasy, Drama, Comedy · 1h 44m · PG · Where to watch: Disney Plus

Shares the same late-80s blend of wish-fulfillment fantasy, romance, and a gentle studio-comedy tone.

Enchanted

2007 · Comedy, Family, Fantasy · 1h 47m · PG · Where to watch: Disney Plus

A polished fairy-tale romance that balances sincerity and comedy while playing with genre expectations.

The Family Man

2000

A sentimental alternate-life romance about fate, missed chances, and the emotional cost of different choices.

The Lake House

2006 · Romance, Drama, Fantasy · 1h 39m · PG

A romantic fantasy centered on impossible connection and the melancholy of love shaped by time.

The Ghost and Mrs. Muir

1947

An elegant supernatural romance with wistfulness, restraint, and a strong sense of emotional atmosphere.

Here Comes Mr. Jordan

1941 · Comedy, Fantasy, Romance · 1h 34m · NR · Where to watch: fuboTV

A classic reincarnation-and-second-chance comedy that helped define the template for this kind of high-concept fantasy.

Heaven Can Wait

1978 · Fantasy, Comedy, Romance · 1h 41m · PG · Where to watch: MGM Plus

A charming body-swap/afterlife comedy that mixes romance, fate, and a light touch with metaphysical ideas.

Always

1989

A romantic fantasy about love, loss, and lingering presence, with a similarly earnest late-80s sensibility.

The Butcher's Wife

1991

A whimsical romantic fantasy with a broad studio-comedy approach and a strong interest in destiny and attraction.

Themes

reincarnation, fate and second chances, memory and identity, afterlife fantasy, forbidden attraction, romantic comedy, family dynamics, 1980s studio charm

Topics

fantasy romance, romantic comedy, reincarnation, afterlife, identity crisis, forbidden love, 1980s, sentimental, offbeat, cult curiosity

Open Chances Are (Fri ) on Curator TV