Curator Watchlist

https://www.curatorwatchlist.com › a-haunting-in-venice

A Haunting in Venice

A moody, gothic mystery with stronger atmosphere than puzzle-box ingenuity. It leans into haunted-house dread, Venice gloom, and a more haunted Poirot, but the mystery itself is fairly transparent and the tonal seriousness may not satisfy viewers expecting a breezier Christie adaptation.

A Haunting in Venice

Where to watch: Buy

Movie · Mystery · Thriller

Wed · 1h 44m

Director: Kenneth Branagh

Starring: Kenneth Branagh, Kyle Allen, Camille Cottin

Overview

Celebrated sleuth Hercule Poirot, now retired and living in self-imposed exile in Venice, reluctantly attends a Halloween séance at a decaying, haunted palazzo. When one of the guests is murdered, the detective is thrust into a sinister world of shadows and secrets.

Director

Kenneth Branagh

Cast

Kenneth Branagh, Kyle Allen, Camille Cottin

Curator Review

Verdict

A moody, gothic mystery with stronger atmosphere than puzzle-box ingenuity. It leans into haunted-house dread, Venice gloom, and a more haunted Poirot, but the mystery itself is fairly transparent and the tonal seriousness may not satisfy viewers expecting a breezier Christie adaptation.

Best for

  • Viewers who like gothic period mysteries
  • Fans of moody, rain-soaked atmosphere and production design
  • Audiences open to a more somber, psychological Poirot
  • People who enjoy ensemble whodunits with a supernatural veneer

Skip if

  • You want a tightly engineered, hard-to-guess mystery
  • You prefer the lighter, more playful side of Agatha Christie
  • You are tired of Kenneth Branagh’s stylized Poirot approach
  • You want a horror film that fully commits to scares

Overview

A Haunting in Venice is the most visually controlled of Kenneth Branagh’s Poirot films, trading the glossy travelogue feel of the earlier entries for damp stone, candlelight, and a genuine sense of enclosure. The Venice setting and Halloween séance framing give it an appealing gothic texture, and the movie is often more effective as mood piece than as whodunit.

Worth noting

The tradeoff is that the central mystery is not especially difficult to solve, and the film’s attempts to deepen the emotional stakes can feel heavier than the material needs. Still, Branagh’s direction is more disciplined here, and the haunted-palazzo setting gives the story a pleasingly sinister shape.

Bottom line

If you come for atmosphere, period detail, and a Poirot who feels more isolated and vulnerable than usual, it delivers. If you want a clever, twisty Christie adaptation that keeps you guessing until the end, this is more likely to be admired than loved.

Top Letterboxd reviews

aliyah · 6134 likes

lots of mysteries in this one like ‘who’s the killer?’ and ‘why is the camera angled like that?’

júlia (3.5★) · 6105 likes

i understand kenneth branagh bc i'm also obsessed with using the 0.5 camera setting feature on my phone

Kevin Tarazi. (3.5★) · 3145 likes

The real crime was that Michelle Yeoh wasn't in every scene.

MarMar (2.5★) · 2770 likes

The twist is so obvious that Benoit Blanc would have solved the case after he had his first drink.

ash (3★) · 2693 likes

I just want someone to love me the way Kenneth Branagh loves using that damn French accent

Recommended similar titles

Death on the Nile

2022 · Mystery, Crime, Thriller · 2h 7m · PG-13 · Where to watch: Hulu, fuboTV, FXNow

Another Branagh Poirot film that pairs lavish period style with an ensemble mystery and a more theatrical, heightened tone.

Murder on the Orient Express

2017 · Mystery, Drama, Crime · 1h 54m · PG-13 · Where to watch: Max

A polished Christie adaptation with ensemble intrigue, old-school star power, and elegant production design.

Knives Out

2019 · Comedy, Crime, Mystery · 2h 11m · PG-13 · Where to watch: fuboTV

A modern whodunit that balances playful suspicion, ensemble dynamics, and a strong sense of style.

Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery

2022 · Comedy, Crime, Mystery · 2h 20m · PG-13 · Where to watch: Netflix

For viewers who enjoy mystery as spectacle, with a glossy setting and a knowingly theatrical tone.

Gosford Park

2001 · Drama, Mystery, Thriller · 2h 17m · R

A class-conscious ensemble mystery where secrets, status, and architecture all matter as much as the crime.

The Last of Sheila

1973

A sharp, game-like mystery with a sinister social circle and a pleasure in misdirection.

The Name of the Rose

1986 · Drama, Thriller, Mystery · 2h 10m · R · Where to watch: Amazon Prime Video, Amazon Prime Video with Ads

A medieval detective story with religious dread, shadowy interiors, and a strong sense of historical atmosphere.

The Innocents

1961 · Horror, Mystery, Drama · 1h 40m · NR · Where to watch: fuboTV

A classic haunted-house film that thrives on ambiguity, repression, and eerie visual control.

The Others

2001 · Horror, Mystery, Thriller · 1h 41m · PG-13 · Where to watch: Philo, AMC+, Shudder

A refined gothic thriller built on isolation, mourning, and a carefully sustained sense of dread.

Rebecca

1940 · Mystery, Romance, Thriller · 2h 10m · NR · Where to watch: Brew

For its haunted estate atmosphere, psychological unease, and elegant gothic melodrama.

Gaslight

1944 · Thriller, Drama, Mystery · 1h 54m · Where to watch: TCM, IndieFlix

A tense, shadowy mystery centered on manipulation, fear, and domestic menace.

Laura

1944 · Drama, Mystery · 1h 28m · Where to watch: Amazon Prime Video, Amazon Prime Video with Ads

A stylish noir mystery with obsession, elegant surfaces, and a famously seductive atmosphere.

Themes

gothic mystery, whodunit, grief and guilt, haunted house, psychological suspense, Halloween, seance, isolation

Topics

gothic, mystery, thriller, whodunit, period piece, Halloween, haunted house, psychological suspense, atmospheric

Open A Haunting in Venice (Wed ) on Curator TV