Curator Watchlist

https://www.curatorwatchlist.com › once-upon-a-time

Once Upon a Time

A glossy, high-concept fairy-tale mashup that starts with a strong hook and a lot of charm, then gradually becomes more uneven as the mythology expands. The early seasons are the sweet spot: inventive, romantic, and surprisingly… Read more

Once Upon a Time

Where to watch: Buy

TV Show · Drama · Sci-Fi & Fantasy

Sun

Created by: Edward Kitsis, Adam Horowitz

Starring: Lana Parrilla, Colin O'Donoghue, Robert Carlyle

Overview

There is a town in Maine where every story book character you've ever known is trapped between two worlds, victims of a powerful curse. Only one knows the truth and only one can break the spell.

Created by

Edward Kitsis, Adam Horowitz

Cast

Lana Parrilla, Colin O'Donoghue, Robert Carlyle, Gabrielle Anwar, Dania Ramirez, Mekia Cox, Andrew J. West, Alison Fernández

Curator Review

Verdict

A glossy, high-concept fairy-tale mashup that starts with a strong hook and a lot of charm, then gradually becomes more uneven as the mythology expands. The early seasons are the sweet spot: inventive, romantic, and surprisingly addictive. Later years are more hit-or-miss, but the show remains a fun comfort watch for viewers who enjoy big ensemble fantasy with soap-opera momentum.

Best for

  • fans of fairy-tale reimaginings
  • viewers who like romantic fantasy with serialized twists
  • people who enjoy ensemble soaps and long-running mythology
  • binge-watchers looking for an escapist network drama

Skip if

  • you want tight plotting and consistent quality throughout
  • you dislike melodrama, resets, or frequent lore expansions
  • you prefer grounded fantasy over whimsical, storybook-style worldbuilding
  • you are looking for a short, self-contained series

Overview

Once Upon a Time is one of the most ambitious network fantasy series of its era, built on a clever premise that turns familiar fairy-tale figures into conflicted, modern-day characters. The first season is especially effective: it balances mystery, romance, and character reveals with a steady sense of wonder, and it makes Storybrooke feel like a place worth returning to.

Worth noting

As the series goes on, the show leans harder into its mythology and crossover-style storytelling, which can be rewarding if you enjoy the expanding web of curses, realms, and family ties. It also becomes more uneven, with some arcs feeling overstuffed or repetitive. Still, the core appeal remains strong: big emotions, memorable villains, and a willingness to remix classic stories in playful ways.

Bottom line

If you’re in the mood for a long, escapist fantasy soap with a strong early payoff, this is an easy recommendation. If you want a more disciplined or consistently polished series, it’s better to sample the first couple of seasons and decide from there.

Recommended similar titles

Grimm

2011 · Where to watch: Amazon Prime Video, Peacock Premium, Amazon Prime Video with Ads, Peacock Premium Plus

A close tonal cousin: modern-day fairy-tale creature lore, procedural structure, and an accessible network-fantasy rhythm.

The Magicians

2015

Sharper, darker fantasy with ensemble dynamics and a strong sense of evolving mythology, especially for viewers who like genre mashups.

Merlin

2008 · Where to watch: Amazon Prime Video, Amazon Prime Video with Ads, Pluto TV, Amazon Prime Video Free with Ads, Tubi TV, Amazon MX Player

A warm, adventure-forward fantasy series that reworks legend with romance, friendship, and a long-form destiny arc.

Galavant

2015

For viewers who enjoy fairy-tale playfulness, this is a witty, musical, self-aware spin on storybook fantasy.

Pushing Daisies

2007

A whimsical, highly stylized fantasy dramedy with a fairy-tale sensibility, romance, and a bright network-TV charm.

The Sandman

2022 · Where to watch: Netflix

More literary and atmospheric, but similarly rooted in mythic storytelling, magical realms, and iconic characters reimagined.

Buffy the Vampire Slayer

1997 · Where to watch: Disney Plus, Hulu

A foundational genre blend of monster-of-the-week storytelling, emotional arcs, and evolving mythology.

Supernatural

2005 · Where to watch: Amazon Prime Video, Peacock Premium, Amazon Prime Video with Ads, Peacock Premium Plus

A long-running brotherly adventure with folklore, monsters, and the same kind of bingeable mythology escalation.

The Vampire Diaries

2009 · Where to watch: Peacock Premium, Max, Peacock Premium Plus

A glossy supernatural soap with romance, family secrets, and escalating magical lore that fans of network fantasy often enjoy.

Charmed

1998

A sister-centered supernatural series with case-of-the-week energy, mythology, and a strong comfort-watch appeal.

Legend of the Seeker

2008

An earnest, adventure-driven fantasy series with classic quest energy and broad, accessible storytelling.

Themes

fairy tales, curses, identity, family, redemption, good vs evil, magic, alternate worlds

Topics

fantasy drama, fairy-tale adaptation, ensemble cast, mystery box, romantic soap opera, network television, whimsical tone, mythology-heavy, 2010s TV, episodic-to-serialized

Open Once Upon a Time (Sun ) on Curator TV