Curator Watchlist

https://www.curatorwatchlist.com › you-can-t-take-it-with-you

You Can't Take It with You

A warm, fast-moving Capra comedy that blends screwball romance with a sincere celebration of eccentricity, generosity, and anti-snobbery. It’s especially rewarding if you like old-Hollywood charm, ensemble chaos, and an optimistic worldview that still lands emotionally.

You Can't Take It with You

Where to watch: Buy

Movie · Comedy · Romance

Thu · 2h 6m

Director: Frank Capra

Starring: Jean Arthur, Lionel Barrymore, James Stewart

Overview

Alice, the only relatively normal member of the eccentric Sycamore family, falls in love with Tony Kirby, but his wealthy banker father and snobbish mother strongly disapprove of the match. When the Kirbys are invited to dinner to become better acquainted with their future in-laws, things don't turn out the way Alice had hoped.

Director

Frank Capra

Cast

Jean Arthur, Lionel Barrymore, James Stewart

Curator Review

Verdict

A warm, fast-moving Capra comedy that blends screwball romance with a sincere celebration of eccentricity, generosity, and anti-snobbery. It’s especially rewarding if you like old-Hollywood charm, ensemble chaos, and an optimistic worldview that still lands emotionally.

Best for

  • Fans of classic Hollywood comedies
  • Viewers who enjoy wholesome, idealistic romance
  • People who like eccentric family ensembles and social satire
  • Anyone in the mood for a feel-good movie with wit and heart

Skip if

  • You prefer sharper, more cynical comedy
  • You need a tightly focused romance with little subplot detour
  • Capra-style sentimentality tends to feel too sugary
  • You dislike broad 1930s theatrical performance styles

Overview

Frank Capra turns a wildly eccentric family into a manifesto for human kindness, and the result is both funny and disarming. The movie thrives on contrast: the Sycamores’ joyful chaos against the Kirbys’ moneyed rigidity, with the romance giving the whole thing a sweet, accessible center. It’s a comedy of manners, but one that keeps insisting that joy, labor, and affection matter more than status.

Worth noting

What makes it endure is the balance of broad comedy and genuine feeling. Some of the early scenes play big, but the film keeps finding richer emotional texture as it goes, especially in the way it treats family as a chosen ecosystem rather than a social credential. James Stewart and Jean Arthur bring a spark that makes the idealism feel lived-in instead of abstract.

Bottom line

This is one of those classic studio films that understands how to be both comforting and pointed. It’s not subtle about its values, but it is remarkably effective at making those values feel contagious. If you’re open to Capra’s earnestness, it’s a delight.

Top Letterboxd reviews

mia lee vicino (4★) · 809 likes

been watching a lot of capra movies recently (for jean arthur specifically) and consistently find myself wishing that the whole runtime was dedicated to the lead characters' respective romances? i know the larger themes of all-american idealism and wholesome human kindness are the ultimate point of his films and a crucial factor as to why they're so revered, but then jimmy stewart will say some shit to jean like, "You're so beautiful. Like, sometimes you're so beautiful it just gags

eely (4★) · 605 likes

i just want jimmy stewart to accept me and my quirky ass family, even if my father sometimes tries to blow up the house with fireworks and my sister’s russian dance teacher (who is always at our house for some reason) sometimes picks people up and slams them down onto the living room floor without their consent. is that too much to ask

Lara Pop (4★) · 454 likes

Forget about its timeless moral message. This movie has Jean Arthur swinging down the banister wearing suspenders adorned with flowers, shouting merrily 'Wheeee, WITHOUT HOLDING!!!' just days after walking into a fancy restaurant with a sign accidentally left on her back reading 'NUTS' in big bright letters. Suffice to say, I was sold right away.

hannah (4.5★) · 412 likes

jimmy stewart invented solar power confirmed

Christopher Moore (4.5★) · 287 likes

Even the cynic in me finds it hard to resist Frank Capra's gushy oddball optimism.

Recommended similar titles

Mr. Deeds Goes to Town

1936 · Comedy, Drama, Romance · 1h 55m · NR

Another Capra comedy about decency colliding with wealth, with the same blend of idealism, satire, and populist warmth.

It Happened One Night

1934 · Comedy, Romance · 1h 45m · NR

A defining screwball romance with Capra’s brisk pacing, chemistry, and affectionate view of ordinary people.

The Awful Truth

1937 · Comedy, Romance · 1h 31m · NR

For classic-era romantic comedy fans who want sharper banter and more sophisticated relationship games.

Bringing Up Baby

1938 · Comedy, Romance · 1h 42m · NR

Shares the manic energy of eccentricity and social disruption, with a wildly playful screwball tone.

The Philadelphia Story

1940 · Comedy, Romance · 1h 53m · NR · Where to watch: Philo

Another elegant comedy of class, romance, and social performance, with sparkling dialogue and star chemistry.

My Man Godfrey

1936 · Comedy · 1h 35m · NR · Where to watch: Amazon Prime Video, Pure Flix, FlixFling, IndieFlix, Amazon Prime Video with Ads, Artiflix

A rich-family comedy that satirizes privilege while embracing chaos, wit, and a surprisingly tender heart.

Meet John Doe

1941

Capra’s idealism in a more overtly civic, populist register, with a similar faith in ordinary people.

The Lady Eve

1941 · Comedy, Romance · 1h 37m

A sophisticated romantic comedy with bite, deception, and one of the great classic-era comic pairings.

Holiday

1938

For a nearby blend of romance, class tension, and a critique of moneyed respectability.

The More the Merrier

1943 · Comedy, Romance · 1h 44m

A buoyant wartime comedy that mixes romance, cramped domestic chaos, and generous human feeling.

Adam's Rib

1949

If you like smart romantic sparring and social observation, this offers wit with a more modern edge.

The Shop Around the Corner

1940 · Comedy, Drama, Romance · 1h 39m · NR · Where to watch: Philo

A tender, character-driven romance with warmth, workplace texture, and understated emotional payoff.

Themes

class conflict, eccentric family, romantic comedy, anti-snobbery, humanism, idealism, generational values, community

Topics

classic Hollywood, screwball comedy, feel-good, ensemble cast, 1930s, romantic, social satire, wholesome, sentimental, family dynamics

Open You Can't Take It with You (Thu ) on Curator TV