Curator Watchlist

https://www.curatorwatchlist.com › the-general

The General

A landmark silent action-comedy with astonishing physical stunt work, crisp visual storytelling, and a surprisingly strong romantic throughline. Its Civil War setting is politically dated and morally compromised, but as a piece of cinematic craft it remains essential.

The General

Where to watch: Buy

Movie · Action · Adventure

Sat · 1h 19m

Director: Clyde Bruckman, Buster Keaton

Starring: Buster Keaton, Marion Mack, Glen Cavender

Overview

During America’s Civil War, Union spies steal engineer Johnny Gray's beloved locomotive, 'The General'—with Johnnie's lady love aboard an attached boxcar—and he single-handedly must do all in his power to both get The General back and to rescue Annabelle.

Director

Clyde Bruckman, Buster Keaton

Cast

Buster Keaton, Marion Mack, Glen Cavender

Curator Review

Verdict

A landmark silent action-comedy with astonishing physical stunt work, crisp visual storytelling, and a surprisingly strong romantic throughline. Its Civil War setting is politically dated and morally compromised, but as a piece of cinematic craft it remains essential.

Best for

  • silent cinema fans
  • action-comedy viewers
  • film history enthusiasts
  • stunt and practical-effects devotees
  • romance-with-adventure audiences

Skip if

  • you want modern pacing and dialogue-heavy storytelling
  • you are sensitive to Confederate romanticization
  • you prefer historically progressive or politically neutral classics
  • silent films are an automatic turnoff

Overview

The General is one of the great demonstrations of what cinema can do without words. Keaton turns a simple chase premise into a machine of escalating gags, precision timing, and jaw-dropping physical danger, all staged with a clarity that still feels modern. The train action is the headline, but the film’s real achievement is how effortlessly it blends comedy, suspense, and romance into a single forward drive.

Worth noting

What keeps it from being an unqualified recommendation is the Civil War framing, which treats the Confederate side with a casualness that can be hard to ignore. That context matters, and it can complicate the experience even when the filmmaking is undeniable. Still, the film’s craftsmanship is so extraordinary that it remains a foundational work of action cinema.

Bottom line

If you love practical stunts, silent-era physical performance, or the feeling of a movie inventing the grammar of its genre in real time, this is indispensable. If you need your classics to be politically comfortable, this is a tougher watch. Either way, it’s a major film that earns its reputation.

Top Letterboxd reviews

Georgia Coley (5★) · 3086 likes

Mad Max: Fury Railroad

Julien Faddoul (5★) · 2578 likes

I'm not sure why people scoff at old movies. They are still new to those who have not seen them.

Wes (5★) · 1650 likes

i dont wanna hear jack shit about tom cruise's stunts in those mission impossible movies when buster keaton managed to do what he did in a film this romantic and grand that was released almost 100 years ago

CinemaVoid 🏴‍☠️ (4★) · 1198 likes

I’m having one helluva time watching confederate propaganda dressed as slapstick. Cinema is dangerous.

sarah (4★) · 1135 likes

Imagine escaping death this many times in one film.... The devil works hard, but Buster Keaton works harder.

Recommended similar titles

The Navigator

1924

Another Keaton showcase that pairs deadpan physical comedy with elaborate set-piece engineering and a strong sense of visual invention.

Steamboat Bill, Jr.

1928

For viewers drawn to monumental stunt work and precision-built comic chaos, especially in a high-stakes action-comedy framework.

Safety Last!

1923

A silent-era masterwork of escalating physical comedy and suspense, with iconic stunt choreography and clean visual storytelling.

City Lights

1931 · Comedy, Drama, Romance · 1h 27m · G · Where to watch: Amazon Prime Video, Max, Amazon Prime Video with Ads

If the romantic element is a big part of the appeal, this offers a tender, emotionally rich silent-era counterpart.

Modern Times

1936 · Comedy, Drama, Romance · 1h 27m · G · Where to watch: Amazon Prime Video, Max, Amazon Prime Video with Ads

Shares the blend of comedy, mechanical peril, and human resilience, with a similarly elegant command of physical gags.

The Gold Rush

1925 · Adventure, Comedy, Drama · 1h 35m · NR · Where to watch: History Vault, Eternal Family, Max

A classic silent comedy that balances broad humor, hardship, and romantic longing with unforgettable set pieces.

The Kid

1921 · Comedy, Drama · 1h 8m · NR · Where to watch: fuboTV, Philo, MGM Plus, Pure Flix, FlixFling, Max, Bloodstream

For audiences who respond to silent-era emotion and physical comedy working together with unusual warmth.

The Circus

1928 · Comedy, Romance, Drama · 1h 12m · G · Where to watch: Amazon Prime Video, FlixFling, Max, Amazon Prime Video with Ads

Another essential silent comedy built on ingenious staging, chase energy, and the art of making danger funny.

The Cameraman

1928

A charming silent comedy with escalating mishaps, romantic interest, and a lovable underdog lead.

The Freshman

1925

A sports-comedy cousin to this film’s underdog energy, with a similarly precise sense of comic escalation.

The Big Parade

1925

For viewers interested in silent-era war settings, though with a more serious and emotionally expansive approach.

Wings

1927 · Drama, Action, War · 2h 24m · PG-13

A landmark of early action spectacle and practical aerial filmmaking, ideal for fans of ambitious physical cinema.

Themes

silent cinema, physical comedy, train chase, war backdrop, romantic rescue, practical stunts, escapist adventure, historical setting

Topics

silent film, slapstick, action-comedy, Civil War, train chase, practical stunts, romance, adventure, classic cinema, physical performance

Open The General (Sat ) on Curator TV